Battle Reviews

All battles and free missions are rated on a scale of 0 to 5 with 0 being the lowest and 5 being the highest. Every month, the Tactical Office posts reviews members have made about other EH battles posted on the Battle Center

TIE-TC Battle #1 - Capture of Zaarin
Average rating: 2.4 (26 total reviews)
LCM CyberShadow
Rating: 2
16/07/2002 7:04:00 AM


Decent battle, I would have given it a 3 if the grammar wasn't so horrible. In mission 5 the Assault Transport enters hyperspace even w/ the enemy Interdictor sitting there, and you can just hit Q Space to quit the mission, which kind of defeats the Interdictor's purpose.


TIE-TC Battle #2 - Strike at Calamari
Average rating: 3.1 (19 total reviews)
LT Big-J-Q
Rating: 2
10/07/2002 10:51:00 PM


A playable battle; Nothing too bad but also nothing too interesting.
Some missions reek of killkillkill, but fortunately not too much.
I could almost say that the biggest problem was that the battle was a bit
amateurish: spelling errors, briefing design errors, starships with
starfighter orders and so on.


TIE-TC Battle #3 - New Dimensions
Average rating: 3.5 (14 total reviews)
CM Zekk Terrik
Rating: 1
8/07/2002 6:10:00 PM


This battle sucked bad. The waiting periods were very irritating and some of the missions seemed designed just to fill up space rather than advance the plotline.

LT Big-J-Q
Rating: 2
10/07/2002 10:57:00 PM


Enjoyable battle although nothing too great. A couple of missions are a bit
"destroy this and that and those", but no waves after waves after waves
after waves...after waves of 6 A-, B-, X- and Y-Wings.

Briefings need a little trimming.


TIE-TC Battle #4 - Recapture Zaarins Technology
Average rating: 2.4 (12 total reviews)
LT Big-J-Q
Rating: 1
10/07/2002 10:58:00 PM


Yet-another-boring-battle. The plot is completely uninteresting and stupid. Just destroy lots of capital ships <yawn>.


TIE-TC Battle #6 - Destruction
Average rating: 1.3 (21 total reviews)
LCM Alexi Stukov
Rating: 1
6/07/2002 7:54:00 PM


Well, since this is before Endor, the Rebels put at least 90% of there forces into that platform. I mean, COME ONE!!! There's a seemingly limitless wave of fighters 5 times over. Your wingmen are worthless, missiles everywhere, LONG missions, no plot, no point, my hand hurt, briefings were that kind where you can't fast forward. To sum it up, don't fly this unless it's for a citation, like me.


TIE-TC Battle #10 - Battle for the DeathStar
Average rating: 3.6 (17 total reviews)
LCM Alexi Stukov
Rating: 4
15/07/2002 11:16:00 AM


Latly, I've been playing alot of crummy TIE battes, so this is a nic change of pace with good old capital ship destroying. Nicely designed and briefings look professional. Your wingmates are helpful and you can actally rely on them. However, I don't have TIE95, so I couldn't enjoy the new planets.


TIE-TC Battle #12 - Jedi Hunt
Average rating: 3.2 (8 total reviews)
LCM Hape Unger
Rating: 3
16/07/2002 4:50:00 PM


Well, I didn´tlike the story but the dogfighting was fun.


TIE-TC Battle #13 - Finding the Lakul
Average rating: 3.6 (8 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
23/07/2002 11:30:00 PM


Well, this was a fun and interesting battle with good briefings and a pretty good story so I do recommend it. However, the last battle will be a bit annoying and the battle is easy overall. Pilots of some skill will have no difficulty blasting through this. It’s a good source for quick FCHG points if you need them for some reason, as it is an easy 6-mission battle. I give it a 4.40 (rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-TC Battle #19 - The Tethys Honeymoon
Average rating: 4.1 (7 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
2/07/2002 3:26:00 PM


This is a good overall battle. It’s interesting, fun, exciting, and challenging without being too frustrating, despite some of the annoyances with the bonus goals and with mission 3. It’s got a nice variety of craft to fly, craft to kill, and types of missions to complete. I’m going to recommend this to people who have flown most of the highest rated battles and are looking for a fun battle that was created back near the beginning of TIE Fighter editing. It’s a good battle and you should enjoy it. I give it a 3.85 (Rounded up to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale)(Note: My full review is more detailed. If you'd like a copy I'd be happy to e-mail it to you, but without the line breaks here it wouldn't look sloppy posted :) )


TIE-TC Battle #27 - (X)-Wings of Glory
Average rating: 3 (10 total reviews)
CM Red Fox
Rating: 4
18/07/2002 2:06:00 PM


I dont know what the guys have. The story is a good one, also the empire can run short of fighters and then must improve and increase the stock by enemy ones. Remember the original battle you flew in a TB an escort, same principle.

Not a five because the installation of the patch is a patience battle and you need a great commander giving you the right patch. *g*


TIE-TC Battle #29 - Communications Wars
Average rating: 3.2 (4 total reviews)
LCM Alexi Stukov
Rating: 3
17/07/2002 8:24:00 PM


Seemed like it was a wave after wave dogfighting battle.


TIE-TC Battle #33 - Strike at Incom
Average rating: 4 (6 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
4/07/2002 3:42:00 AM


This truly is a fantastic battle. It’s fun, fairly easy, interesting, and well written. There are the problems with the briefings being uninteresting and short along with not having a mission critical ATR being mission critical which can cause some problems in mission 4, it is great. It might be a little short and might be a little easy, but I recommend this battle to everyone. I had a great time flying it.I give it a 4.75(Rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale)


TIE-TC Battle #44 - Military Complex Operation
Average rating: 4.2 (4 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
7/07/2002 9:06:00 PM


Well, this is a fun battle and I do recommend it. I really wish the failed mission hints were a bit more helpful in missions 2 and 5 and I really wish that I wasn’t required to alter my standard armament in mission 2 to make sure that Cal Cruiser doesn’t get in the way of the Cargo Ferries. Most importantly I wish that the author didn’t choose to use waves of fighters in mission 4. That was the biggest let down for me. It’s still a good battle though and I suggest that you all fly it. I give it a 4.35 (rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale)


TIE-TC Battle #48 - "Ski Hoth" - Star Wars Mercenaries
Average rating: 4.2 (6 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
2/07/2002 3:23:00 PM


I found myself having a lot of fun with this battle. It was filled with lots of different things to blow up along with the fact that you get to mess around with Star Tours. I think that idea makes a pretty good plotline even though the plot itself was a bit lackluster. This mission is a bit easy and as a result, serious pilots might want to look elsewhere for a challenge. Also, those of you put off by the Missile Boat would do well to avoid the battle. But for the rest of us this battle is great for blowing off some steam after a hard day. The devastating power of the Missile Boat with a double load of warheads is a great way to wind down the day.
I give it a 4.45 (Rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale)(Note: My full review is much more detailed. If you'd like a copy, I'd be happy to e-mail you one, but without line breaks it looks sloppy here :) )


TIE-TC Battle #52 - Freedom Task Force
Average rating: 3 (5 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
23/07/2002 11:32:00 PM


It was a pretty good battle with an interesting plot and some pretty well crafted missions. However, that “bug” in the last mission almost ruins it. It is rather frustrating to have to kill things so quickly because they’ll just run into the Interdictor. If it’s a bug, it deserves to lose score for that and if it’s intentional the battle deserves to lose more. Still, it’s a fun battle and I do recommend it. Just watch out for those capital ships ramming the Interdictor. I give it a 3.70 (rounded up to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-TC Battle #54 - Excaliber
Average rating: 1.7 (3 total reviews)
MAJ Azazel
Rating: 0
3/07/2002 5:36:00 AM


o my god ! it is long i have played so stupid battle ...x-wing against t/d who are we rebs or imerials? beware of that battle


TIE-TC Battle #58 - The Outcast
Average rating: 2.3 (3 total reviews)
CPT Badlan
Rating: 4
26/07/2002 3:49:00 PM


I actually really liked this, the dialogue as well as plot was good. There was no main 'plot' it was simply about a pilot whom was shamed. Which had a realistic, 'just another day at the office' feel. The last mission, which seemed completely off-topic was also interesting. I also like the variating missions and the fact that just because you can put a load of fighters in a mission doesn't mean you should! A Squadron or two per battle is okay and gives a reasonable, realistic edge. Good battle.


TIE-TC Battle #64 - Pruscian Betrayal, Part I
Average rating: 3.1 (8 total reviews)
LCM Repulsor
Rating: 4
25/07/2002 1:18:00 PM


Incredible plot. I enjoyed mission 1 very much. One of the best battles in story, though the Imperial Arsenal is a bit weak against that opposition.


TIE-TC Battle #76 - Mirror Universe
Average rating: 4.5 (35 total reviews)
LT Big-J-Q
Rating: 3
12/07/2002 10:11:00 AM


Well... Interesting plot for once, reminds me of Star Trek... Too bad
TIE (disk/CD/95) engine doesn't let you achieve great effects needed for this kind of battles.

I don't know if I should rate this battle 3 or 4. Although the idea was
fresh (?), the technical side is still a little unprofessional. The battle
lacked that something that can be sensed in LA battles.

But all in all, it's definitely worth your time!

LCM Alexi Stukov
Rating: 0
24/07/2002 1:14:00 PM


I find this battle one of the worst I've played. Friendly A.I. was poor, plot was confusing, ridiculously long missions. I greatly anticipated what would happen at the end of mission 6 but sadly was possibly the most dissapointing endings. You are suppoused to fly into the Container Transport and wait for the Interdictor and there is suppoused to be a spectacular explosion propelling you to your universe. Now, here's what really happend. I'm fling to the Trasport and all of a sudden, the Interdictor consumes the ship, blocking my entry. 6 TIE Defenders fly in, and the Transport is destroyed, the other 3 TIEs ram the Interdictor forcing me to destroy it. If I had been inside the Transport, I would have died and wasted 30 minutes playing the single worst mission ever created by this club.


TIE-TC Battle #77 - Verpine Encounter, Part One
Average rating: 4.1 (24 total reviews)
LT Mulder
Rating: 4
1/07/2002 6:24:00 PM


Despite the missions being very long and for the most part very easy, this battle is put together very well and has a nice storyline. Highly recommended.

LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
4/07/2002 3:44:00 AM


Well, this was an excellent battle. It is filled with a good plot, fun officer briefings, craft variety in both opponents and piloted craft, and it is challenging without being frustrating. Some of the bonus goals are confusing to figure out or are hard to complete but that really doesn’t detract from the battle too much. It is an excellent overall battle. I give it a4.85 (Rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale).


TIE-TC Battle #78 - Verpine Encounter, Part Two
Average rating: 4.6 (8 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
4/07/2002 3:45:00 AM


Its truly hard for me to judge this battle independently as it does truly belong in a series with battle 77. Still, I should try to judge it on its own merits and this one just isn’t quite as good. Its still well written like its predecessor and has some fun missions for sure, but those difficulty hops were a bit hard to swallow. On the plus side, its bonus goals are either non-existent or easier to figure out, which is an improvement over the first battle in this series. Those last two missions are what keep me from giving this one a 5 however. If mission 4 wasn’t so easy then so hard all at the same time due to those new fighters with Adv. Concussion missiles and if the last mission wasn’t so easy that I could finish it in 5 minutes this battle would have walked away with a 5. Still, I recommend this battle wholeheartedly especially if you have already played battle 77. You owe yourself the pleasure of finishing off the series that was so well written.
I give it a 4.40 (Rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale)


TIE-TC Battle #87 - Withdrawal From Endor
Average rating: 3 (7 total reviews)
CM Andrew
Rating: 1
1/07/2002 8:09:00 PM


Not bad, but you have to wait way, way too long on numerous occasions.


TIE-TC Battle #91 - Supply Incident
Average rating: 1.3 (3 total reviews)
CM Andrew
Rating: 1
2/07/2002 8:09:00 PM


Bad.


TIE-TC Battle #96 - Deep Strike
Average rating: 4.4 (5 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
11/07/2002 2:53:00 PM


Well, the battle’s plot is fairly average, the first and last missions have some annoying qualities too them, and it’s a tad easy overall. Still, the briefings are well done and most of the battle is fun and entertaining and that’s really what we are all about here in the EH so I will give it a solid recommendation. Go fly and enjoy! I give it a 4.25 (rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale).


TIE-TC Battle #104 - Spam Wars
Average rating: 4.2 (5 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
2/07/2002 3:30:00 PM


Well, this is a pretty fun battle that can be finished quickly. The first 3 missions are easy and short, the 4th mission is fun, and the 5th almost ruins it between the bug that keeps the Reserves that show up attacking the Platform, the bug that has the TRNs boarding the containers rather than capturing them, keeping the secondary goals from being completed, and the rather uninspired naming and use of wings. Still it’s a fun battle that I recommend to anyone who can overlook that last mission.
I give it a 3.80 (Round up to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale)(Note: My full review is more detailed. I'd be happy to mail you a copy if you'd like one, but here without the line breaks it'd would look sloppy :) )


TIE-TC Battle #108 - Unexplored Territory
Average rating: 4 (12 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
23/07/2002 11:39:00 PM


I liked this battles plot and I enjoyed blowing up capital ships with a few star fighters on the side. The briefings are well done and it’s a fun battle overall to play. However, if you are looking for a challenge, this battle really isn’t for you. It’s pretty easy to finish the entire 4-mission battle in 30 minutes on hard, so look elsewhere for a difficult battle. Otherwise, fly and enjoy. I give it a 4.30 (rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale).


TIE-TC Battle #114 - Stop the Press!
Average rating: 4.5 (4 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
11/07/2002 2:54:00 PM


This was a fun battle that had a great and fun plot to it. Too bad it’s a bit hard for the newcomer even on Medium difficulty. A few less wings and objectives are difficult to complete would have helped. Also, making a T/A kill an Escort Carrier that jumps to hyperspace after you kill its fighters is a bit rough. I would have liked a bit more time to kill that. For those who don’t know, I’m referring to mission 1 there. Anyway, it is interesting and I do recommend it, just be prepared for a bit of a challenge. I give it a 4.15 (rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-TC Battle #118 - Omicron's Initiation
Average rating: 4.3 (3 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
7/07/2002 9:03:00 PM


This is a pretty good battle. I had fun playing it and while it is enjoyable to destroy stuff, there were too many older star fighters in the battle to kill. Excessive use of wings and a sort of common, though well thought out, plotline also lowers the score. Another thing is that fighting A-Wings in an Assault Gunboat can be tad frustrating, but not too bad. I will recommend this battle, but I’d go searching for something more like Battle 200 or Battle 76, 77, and 78. Those are better, but this is still pretty good. I give it a 4.00 (kept at a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-TC Battle #131 - TIE Fighter Covert Missions
Average rating: 3.1 (15 total reviews)
LCM HicRic
Rating: 4
13/07/2002 4:18:00 AM


Great battle, well worth flying. Not as hard as you'd think, either-seeing as you have no shields, except for the last mission.
Very solid mission design, and very recommeded. =)


TIE-TC Battle #132 - Battle of the Bins
Average rating: 4.1 (14 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
23/07/2002 11:45:00 PM


This is a funny and interesting battle that I recommend. There are good briefings, lots of stuff to kill, and A-Team references. There are a couple of flaws like an annoying mission 2 and having to help TIE Defenders disable craft in a Missile Boat in mission 3, but it’s still a good overall battle. It’s not too challenging and its fun to play. I give it a 4.40 (rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-TC Battle #133 - Punishment Tour
Average rating: 4.3 (71 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
12/07/2002 1:18:00 AM


This mission is funny, well written, and fun to play with the exception of one mission where you must do way more than your craft can handle. Putting me against X-Wings and A-Wings in a TIE Fighter was a bit rough for a battle that was essentially supposed to be a bit of a joke. I loved this battle, but that mission almost ruined it for me. Still, I can see why everyone likes it and because the author decided not to put missiles on those A-Wings and X-Wings mentioned above, I’m going to go ahead and round my score up instead of rounding it down. I give it a 4.5 (rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale).

LC Jon Doyle
Rating: 0
22/07/2002 1:26:00 PM


Do not ever fly this battle for a competition. It's fun the first time you fly it, after then I'd rather jump off a bridge


TIE-TC Battle #134 - Damaged TIEs
Average rating: 4.3 (15 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
11/07/2002 2:58:00 PM


This is a fun battle, but don’t play it if you are looking for an easy battle. It contains some nifty ideas and you get to fly some rebel craft, which is cool, if you are sick of flying the typical Imperial Craft. You get to see what it’s like to be in the Infiltrator Wing :). Its briefings are well done and the story is interesting and unique. I recommend this battle strongly if you are looking for a change of pace. I give it a 4.35 (rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale)


TIE-TC Battle #166 - Strike of the Hammer
Average rating: 4.1 (8 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
23/07/2002 11:36:00 PM


This is a great battle and I recommend it strongly. There is an interesting plot, lots of action, good briefings, and fun missions. There are some slight problems, like the capital ships having star fighter orders and advanced concussion missiles against a TIE Advanced is never fun, but it’s a great battle over all. Go fly and enjoy. I give it a 4.70 (rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale


TIE-TC Battle #168 - Project Omega
Average rating: 4.5 (2 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
23/07/2002 11:34:00 PM


This battle is great fun with a good story. There are well-designed battles, good briefings, and lots of action. There are some problems with the last missions, but they are overlookable generally speaking. There is also room for a sequel at the end, which is always a good thing if you enjoyed the battle like I did this one. All and all this is a great battle, which I strongly recommend. I give it a 4.70 (rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-TC Battle #171 - Fury of the Colossus
Average rating: 4.6 (19 total reviews)
LT Serin Jansj
Rating: 4
23/07/2002 3:49:00 PM


I was impressed by the battle, to say the least. All of the missions are very cool and even evoke a real battle atmosphere, but... the last mission felt undone. I'm not really sure why the stealth thing was really needed in hindsight (aside from furthering the story a slight bit). But, who am I to critique? The story and the briefings (excellent animation I think) were both great. Overall, a great battle - definitely worthy of eveyone's time.


TIE-TC Battle #178 - Ghosts of Endor
Average rating: 4 (8 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 3
12/07/2002 1:19:00 AM


It’s a pretty good battle with two fatal flaws that involve the difficulty of the battle in which you have to disable the CORT and just how long and pointless the last mission is (any battle with an 11 minute wait period just isn’t that well thought out). I can’t wholeheartedly recommend this battle since it is 8 missions long and will take a long time, especially considering that last battle. I really would have given this battle a lot higher if those two missions didn’t ruin the battle for me. It basically took me all day to finish and I wasn’t happy when I was done, just relieved. I give it a 2.90 (rounded up to a 3 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-TC Battle #180 - The Virus
Average rating: 2.5 (4 total reviews)
MAJ Azazel
Rating: 1
17/07/2002 6:29:00 AM


i must say this battle maybe has original plotline but rest is horrible , you dont know whats going on ..on second mission it is completly mess i hate that kind of battles i would give it 0 but plotline makes i gave it 1


TIE-TC Battle #183 - Defection of Kusanagi
Average rating: 5 (1 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
4/07/2002 3:47:00 AM


This was a fun battle with an interesting plot. It’s not too hard and can be finished fairly quickly, but watch out for mission 4. Be sure to protect those Missile Boats and you may need to call for reinforcements. I recommend this mission for pilots that are looking for an interesting battle. I give it a 4.5 (Rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale)


TIE-TC Battle #185 - Joining the Heroes
Average rating: 4.1 (9 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 3
23/07/2002 11:43:00 PM


The plot line is interesting, the briefings are well done, and most of the missions are fun to play so it’s a shame that with the rest of the battle so good, it ruined by the worst mission I’ve ever played. The last mission is so bad that I’m giving this battle 1.5 points lower than I would have otherwise. There is no reason for the insane jump in difficulty in the end. I tried it on hard without reinforcements and I couldn’t pass. I tried on hard with reinforcements and I couldn’t pass. I tried it on medium without reinforcements and I couldn’t pass. I tried it on medium with reinforcements and I couldn’t pass. Finally I beat it on easy without reinforcements. If I can’t even beat it on medium with reinforcements it’s probably too hard of a mission for a battle in which I beat the entirety of the other missions on hard with no aid. That last mission shouldn’t have been and I’m sorry to see a good battle go down in flames like this. I’m recommending it marginally, but you might not get past that last mission. I give it a 2.90 (rounded up to a 3 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-TC Battle #194 - Terrorist Attack
Average rating: 4 (2 total reviews)
CPT Avantar
Rating: 4
16/07/2002 3:38:00 PM


A good battle, although the last mission is loooooong... Even with full load of warheads.


TIE-TC Battle #195 - Wing II : Inkwolf's Raid
Average rating: 4 (9 total reviews)
CPT Avantar
Rating: 3
17/07/2002 10:11:00 AM


Not bad, but also not good. It's just about killing almost everything in sight. And the last battle - do not destroy CSR in first minutes of the game, as TIE ship limit will prevent you from completing mission.


TIE-TC Battle #196 - Imperial Storm II:Dark Horizon
Average rating: 1.7 (7 total reviews)
CPT Carl Lost
Rating: 2
4/07/2002 11:49:00 PM


wellll - whyt 3 battles ? And why this complicated numerating ? XWA seems better suited for this kind of translation fo a maneuver, yes ?


TIE-TC Battle #198 - Prelude to Andevia
Average rating: 3.8 (4 total reviews)
CPT Carl Lost
Rating: 3
4/07/2002 11:47:00 PM


Uuuhm, sometime this battle can get quite frustrating but it is playable and complex - that is good.


TIE-TC Battle #199 - Shinsen Gumi Saga #1 : The School For Scandal
Average rating: 4 (4 total reviews)
CPT Carl Lost
Rating: 4
4/07/2002 11:45:00 PM


Cool plotline and reasonably well gameplay :) I like it !

LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
11/07/2002 5:46:00 PM


This is a fun battle with some interesting missions and funny briefings, provided that you can make it past the first mission without destroying your joystick. I played that mission for several hours last night and 30 minutes this morning and finally beat it. I then raced through the rest of the missions with little difficulty. That’s kind of a poor way to organize the difficulty in a battle. Difficulty should increase as the battle goes along, not decrease. The hardest mission should be at the end so that pilots who have worked really hard to reach the end will want to finish, if for no other reason that to see their work finished. Having the first mission being so difficult will just turn folks away. Still, I recommend it, but I warn the player to be aware of that first step so to speak. I give it a 4.30 (rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-TC Battle #200 - ASCENSION
Average rating: 4.5 (24 total reviews)
CPT Carl Lost
Rating: 5
11/07/2002 9:54:00 PM


I most strongly disagree with CM Ender mBind here. This battle truly rivals TC 184 / mirror universe battles in terms of complexity and storyline. The storyline is good for a short story with its complexity and the gameplay is hazardous enough at times to drive a pilot to insanity. And I may calim I am not a beginner, yes ? It is FUN to fly and it is as FUN and exciting to read the briefings !! I motion for a sequel :)

LT Big-J-Q
Rating: 4
12/07/2002 9:59:00 AM


This one has to be (one of?) the greatest EH battle I've ever played to date. The plot was interesting although in the later missions it became a little
silly. The missions looked professional, and the briefings were even better. However a rating of 5 would indicate a perfect battle, but this is ALMOST perfect. There are some typos, some bugs, the battle was too
easy, even on the hard difficulty setting, and some messages (at least one!)appear when they really shouldn't.

I'd give it a 4 and a half, but I'm afraid I have to round it down.


TIE-IW Battle #24 - Rion's Shadow Campaign: Seeds of Corruption
Average rating: 4 (2 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
11/07/2002 2:56:00 PM


For my first IW battle it was really fun. I’ve been flying TIE Fighters and their ilk far too much recently so using those Rebel fighters was a nice change of pace. So nice, in fact, that I’ll be flying another IW battle next. I thought the story was pretty good; it left room for a sequel (as it is part of a larger campaign) and was fun to dogfight other Rebels in your rebel fighter. I recommend this to anyone who is looking for a change of pace from the usual T/D, T/A, and Missile Boat missions that are in the normal TIE Corps battles. I give it a 4.30 (rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-DB Battle #4 - Baptism of Fire
Average rating: 2.4 (7 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 2
23/07/2002 11:37:00 PM


Bleh, this battle is absolutely awful. Since there are some positives, such as the disturbing nature, and the fairly well worded briefings, I will give this battle a middle range 2. But the excessive goals, both primary and secondary, in combination with bugs and general boring missions make this one to avoid, unless forced to do it for Dark Brotherhood membership like I did. I’m sorry, but this gets my lowest score to date. I give it a 2.25 (rounded down to a 2 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-FCHG Battle #2 - Shadow of Time
Average rating: 4.8 (23 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
7/07/2002 9:26:00 PM


Holy cow is this an excellent battle! I recommend that everyone flies this as it is the best (along with Mirror Universe) that I’ve seen the EH offer in terms of battles. It is well written, has a great plot, lots of action, its not frustrating, its captivating, the briefings are masterfully worked, and there is even a choice of missions in one of the missions for even more variance. Download and play this now. I don’t think you can be disappointed. I give it a 4.95 (rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale.)

LT Big-J-Q
Rating: 4
13/07/2002 12:43:00 PM


An excellent battle. I was especially impressed by mission 5, which is
totally different when played on hard than on easier difficulty setting.
Only minor bugs (typos and such), so I'm tempted to give it a 5 because
of creative innovations, but as it lacks final perfect professional touch,
I'll have to round the rating down to 4.


TIE-FCHG Battle #3 - The Perils of Diplomacy
Average rating: 4.3 (7 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
7/07/2002 9:08:00 PM


God, I loved this battle. I wish more could be like it. The combination of action, excellent briefings and debriefings, a wonderful plot, funny in-jokes, and just great overall use of inventive TIE technology put this almost on par with my old favorite “Mirror Universe.” Still, there wasn’t quite the awestruck feeling as I got with “Mirror Universe” so it’s going to score a whole .05 lower, hehe. I know that’s not much, but “Mirror Universe” does manage to stay on top, just by a bit. I give it a 4.90 (rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-FREE Mission #22 - MFlux #1
Average rating: 3.7 (3 total reviews)
CPT Ponda Jarret
Rating: 4
18/07/2002 7:14:00 AM


Wheeee! This was fun! Thanks for the great mission!


TIE-FREE Mission #82 - Farewell to Renegade
Average rating: 3.6 (5 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
23/07/2002 11:42:00 PM


This is a fun free mission with a pretty good plot and lots to fight. It’s also quite tricky so if you are looking for something easy to fly, don’t’ fly this. I recommend it, but watch out for the difficulty. I give it a 4.55 (rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-FREE Mission #134 - Save the Immortal
Average rating: 4.2 (5 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
23/07/2002 11:49:00 PM


This is a fun mission with good briefings, a well flushed out plot for a free mission, and lots of killing, should you let the star fighters actually make it out. Other than the fact that if you nuke that first capital ship really quickly you can finish the mission quickly, this is a great mission. Play it if you are looking for a fun free mission to get in. I give it a Score: 4.80 (rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-FREE Mission #160 - Colossus: Gold Rush
Average rating: 3.8 (5 total reviews)
LT Curtis
Rating: 5
10/07/2002 3:46:00 AM


Very good, nice plot as beef said can be hard if you destroy the craft in the Wrong order, and Watch out for the the Y-Wings at the end. Nice work AV!


TIE-FREE Mission #161 - Midnight Raid!
Average rating: 4.5 (2 total reviews)
LT Curtis
Rating: 4
10/07/2002 3:59:00 AM


This is a good free mission, Action packed not much waiting time and a Nice plot, In my view it gets 4.5 but I think I give to many 5s as I only rate the good missions/battles.


TIE-FREE Mission #162 - The Trophy
Average rating: 3.3 (3 total reviews)
LT Curtis
Rating: 3
10/07/2002 4:11:00 AM


mad plotline kill the WOOKIE! but the mission is well... average, and pretty easy too. But although this isnt the best ive flown i think it would make a Good competion mission as the secondary goals are hard.


TIE-FREE Mission #163 - Farewell Celebration
Average rating: 3 (4 total reviews)
LT Curtis
Rating: 3
10/07/2002 4:20:00 AM


kill a few X-Wings and blow up a Frigate pretty easy but the plotline is there and you get to fly something other than a T/A,T/D or MIS which is always a bonus.


TIE-FREE Mission #164 - Evacuate Platform
Average rating: 4.5 (2 total reviews)
LT Curtis
Rating: 4
10/07/2002 4:31:00 AM


Evacuate missions are my favourite plotline so this was always going to get a good rating from me. As dujhood said there are no major bugs and its a pretty good free mission


TIE-FREE Mission #165 - Battle of Baraton
Average rating: 2 (1 total reviews)
LT Curtis
Rating: 2
10/07/2002 4:37:00 AM


average mission not really anything that makes it stand out from the rest.


TIE-FREE Mission #166 - Custom Operations
Average rating: 1 (1 total reviews)
LT Curtis
Rating: 1
10/07/2002 4:45:00 AM


Primarys are very easy, which I dont like, I has simple briefings and maps and a simple plotline but there is some chance to score if you do the secondarys


TIE-FREE Mission #167 - I Just Work Here
Average rating: 4.4 (8 total reviews)
LT Curtis
Rating: 4
12/07/2002 3:36:00 AM


Funny Stuff, and well designed to this is a very good free mission but what drops it to a 4 is it is easy and even on hard isnt much challenge at all.


TIE-FREE Mission #187 - Great Ewok Hunt
Average rating: 3 (1 total reviews)
CM Drak
Rating: 3
9/07/2002 8:54:00 AM


Ewok Hunting is 1 of my hobbies so i liked it, shame about the T/D's but who needs wingmen!


TIE-FREE Mission #188 - Reconcile a Rebel Dispute
Average rating: 4.5 (4 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
7/07/2002 9:02:00 PM


This is one of the best free missions that I’ve played. There are some things, like the impossibility of completing all of the bonus goals, that are sort of unfair and annoying, but they can be overlooked. This is a pretty challenging, fun, and well-written mission that I recommend for people to fly when they are looking for just that single mission. I give it a 4.75 (rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale.)


TIE-FREE Mission #189 - Mu's Assault
Average rating: 4 (1 total reviews)
LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 4
4/07/2002 3:48:00 AM


This is a fun mission and I can wholeheartedly recommend this for anyone looking for a nice quick mission to play for some credit. Sure it lacks some plot and those Z-95s required for your secondary goals may not show up, but it does allow you to take out some fighters and an Interdictor in an Assault Gunboat. You’ll feel good when you are done. I give it a 4.40 (Rounded down to a 4 for purposes of the EH review scale).


TIE-FREE Mission #200 - The Expendables
Average rating: 4 (5 total reviews)
LCM DarkEagle
Rating: 4
31/07/2002 4:26:00 PM


Pretty good FM; fun, quick, yet frustrating if you have to repeat it a few times. Just two things:
1. Sometimes the starfighters going after you keep running into the FAC.
2. If 4 T/Ds with adv. concussions go after your fragile T/A, you're dead.


TIE-FREE Mission #204 - ASF: Wasp Squadron
Average rating: 3 (1 total reviews)
LCM Talas
Rating: 3
1/07/2002 10:56:00 AM


3.5 really. Fun mission but losses a point for seemingly endless waves of
X-W's and A-W's (At least they didn't have Adv. missiles :P)


XvT-TC Battle #2 - Capture of a Murderer
Average rating: 2.7 (19 total reviews)
LT Jagged Fel
Rating: 3
5/07/2002 5:38:00 AM


Fairly good. I thought the hardest mission was number 1. The story line was fairly good and I liked the way your wingmen were high leveled.


XvT-TC Battle #3 - Preparing for Battle
Average rating: 3.9 (10 total reviews)
LT Chris Cox
Rating: 4
13/07/2002 12:36:00 AM


A very good battle in my opinion


XvT-TC Battle #4 - Encounter with the Black Sun
Average rating: 1.8 (18 total reviews)
LT Jagged Fel
Rating: 4
7/07/2002 5:04:00 PM


Wow, is all I can say! I like it! I truly think that this is definately a great mission! I loved the first mission! The Tie Interceptor brings back the old days of unshielded craft! Since I love to dogfight, this is a great mission in my eyes!


XvT-TC Battle #5 - Phoenix Saga
Average rating: 4.1 (17 total reviews)
LT Jagged Fel
Rating: 2
8/07/2002 6:36:00 AM


Not bad, but nt the greatest either. I kind of found the absence of high performance Ties a ittle annoying. Also, all you do is dogfight. Throw in a capture or bombing mission now and then.

LCM CyberShadow
Rating: 3
22/07/2002 10:26:00 AM


A decent battle, however, it was pretty much all dogfighting, and the story didn't fit together very well.


XvT-TC Battle #6 - Wolf Pack Aggression
Average rating: 3.7 (20 total reviews)
LT Jagged Fel
Rating: 2
8/07/2002 8:05:00 AM


Everyone seems to love this mission, but I think its just fairly good. I did like the way you could pick between bombing and assisting, but the story line was a little boring. Plus, it was too easy!!!!


XvT-TC Battle #7 - The Resupply
Average rating: 3.2 (17 total reviews)
LT Jagged Fel
Rating: 1
8/07/2002 9:28:00 AM


Too easy, its just too easy! The only mission I even got hit on was the last one. If you could increase the difficulty and numbers of the Rebels on Missions 1-4, it would be great. I did like the idea of having a few stranded fighters, but Tie Advanced! Make it more challenging, use Tie Interceptors.


XvT-TC Battle #9 - The Black Sun Incident
Average rating: 1.4 (14 total reviews)
LCM Joe Arena
Rating: 0
29/07/2002 2:50:00 PM


I dont know what to say, except that its probably the worst battle i've ever flown and it made me wanna puke.


XvT-TC Battle #10 - Abduction of VA Priyum
Average rating: 3.8 (9 total reviews)
LT Jagged Fel
Rating: 3
8/07/2002 5:49:00 PM


Not bad at all. I liked the story line and the missions were of medium difficulty. Good work!


XvT-TC Battle #13 - Graduates, Graduate!
Average rating: 3.2 (6 total reviews)
LT Choosh
Rating: 5
8/07/2002 9:32:00 PM


Great Battle, The first demanded good situational awareness and the second was like an old Zarin mission in TIE fighter, very good, I liked it.

LT Jagged Fel
Rating: 4
10/07/2002 4:00:00 PM


VERY GOOD! The last two missions were incredible with the Imperial, Rebel, Tharn, and alien forces all in a battle! Good work!


XvT-TC Battle #16 - Deep strike at K'atalla
Average rating: 3 (7 total reviews)
LT Choosh
Rating: 1
9/07/2002 12:47:00 PM


I didn't like it. there were too many enemy fighters. once the million fighters were gone my wingmen attacked me. and it'd be nice to do something other than defend the intrepid. And in the 6th mission I had to destroy the asteroid base and cruiser by myself because my wingmen all left.

LCM CyberShadow
Rating: 3
26/07/2002 7:42:00 AM


A decent battle, though defending your Command Ship and dogfighting are about all you do.


XvT-TC Battle #30 - Wing XV: Hornet Squadron
Average rating: 3.3 (3 total reviews)
LCM Joe Arena
Rating: 1
8/07/2002 9:35:00 AM


God forbid any other pilots on your side do anything. On the last mission, the caputre craft fired about three ion shots before being killed. After that, no more capture craft we sent. So i had a fun time sitting around for a half hour with nothing happening. I got some of my homework done during all of it.


XvT-TC Battle #34 - INT Shire 2
Average rating: 4 (3 total reviews)
MAJ Frodo
Rating: 4
17/07/2002 11:13:00 AM


This battle is marvelous! my best work yet! You'll find that my skills in XvTED have improved alot since XvT TC 32


XvT-TC Battle #35 - ASF: Supremacy Comp IV
Average rating: 3.7 (3 total reviews)
CPT Frey Gallandro
Rating: 4
5/07/2002 3:21:00 AM


I really enjoyed the dogfights in this Battle and it was nice to see some well known faces again :)

LCM Darth Angelus
Rating: 4
22/07/2002 5:58:00 AM


I really quite liked this battle, its not difficult but as Ender said you do have to play through each of the missions twice which can get a bit repeatative. Not much in the way of exciting plot developments (the battle is more like a good collection of FREE's) but nicely executed none-the-less.


XvT-TC Battle #36 - Operation: Dark Hammer
Average rating: 3.2 (5 total reviews)
CPT Mage
Rating: 4
28/07/2002 10:14:00 PM


I thoroughly enjoyed this battle. Besides being a neat idea, and a unique battle (by length), it had some easy missions, some hard missions... Overall, I would say it was fun. Not to mention the 18 missions towards Wing XIII's July mission spree, all bundled up in one quick install... :P


XvT-TC Battle #37 - Intrepid to the Rescue
Average rating: 3.7 (3 total reviews)
CPT Mage
Rating: 3
6/07/2002 12:25:00 AM


Ick. While possibly good in original design, this battle lacks a LOT. The first thing I noticed about this battle was the absolute lack of any relation between the missions. It's kind-of like a haphazardly built collection of semi-decent FREEs. Next up - the complete lack of any Imperial values in this battle. Honestly, we're the Emperor's Hammer, not the Alliance Firefighting Platoon. >:P The messages left a lot to desire, the fact that your enemies all came loaded with missiles was annoying, and the goals were just pathetic.

However, that being said, in design the battle is not bad, and offers a good challenge, while not too hard.


XvT-TC Battle #40 - Leaders of the New Republic
Average rating: 4.5 (2 total reviews)
CM Drak
Rating: 4
9/07/2002 7:59:00 AM


Loved this battle especially mission 2 where i flew between a crossfire with a ISD & a Mon Cal twice! hehe idiot ships were supposed to be hitting me.


XvT-TC Battle #41 - More Power Part I
Average rating: 3 (2 total reviews)
CPT Alec Qarni
Rating: 3
20/07/2002 6:20:00 PM


The "More Power" series, in my opinion, should have been compressed into 2 battles of 4 or 5 missions, or 1 8-mission battle. Missions are repeated throughout the series, and the story is stretched out pretty far. Technically, though, it's just peachy, and I wouldn't say it's not worth playing. It's one of those battles where i found myself not caring about the briefings or inflight messages- every mission was very straightforward and simple and the story served as only a light polish on top.


XvT-TC Battle #44 - More Power Part IV
Average rating: 2 (1 total reviews)
CPT Alec Qarni
Rating: 2
20/07/2002 6:14:00 PM


Basically blah. Missions are not really varied, story is only slightly thicker than paper, and it's not really fun. It's technically a-ok, though, and it's really not Pinky Lollipop bad, it's just kinda boring.


XvT-TC Battle #45 - Dark Disciple 1
Average rating: 4.2 (5 total reviews)
CPT Abel Malik
Rating: 4
9/07/2002 4:56:00 PM


A good battle to fly for fun and amusement as well as for the FCHG points. Always nice to kill some rebels:P. The missions were a good mix of difficulties.

LC Guthwulf
Rating: 4
14/07/2002 2:43:00 PM


A nice battle from start to finish. Not terribly hard, but definitely not at all easy. A good overall battle if you are just wanting something enjoyable to play. Plot was very solid and the missions were different enough to keep you interested.

CM TK-7764
Rating: 4
19/07/2002 10:07:00 AM


Finally, a good XvT Battle. I had almost forgot what they where like.

LC Dax Corrin
Rating: 4
19/07/2002 11:10:00 AM


Not too tough at first, but the last 2 gave me a workout! Nice work, Tarks!


XvT-TC Battle #46 - Wing XV: Crossing Borders
Average rating: 3.8 (4 total reviews)
CPT Alec Qarni
Rating: 4
18/07/2002 8:29:00 PM


Not terribly varied, could have been done in maybe 8 or 9 missions instead, but it's all good. Various spelling mistakes, including my own name (again, foolish MB) drag it down the rest of the 1 point. Fun enough to play, with a reasonable storyline and difficulty level, and the usual Ender-quality technical expertise. I'd actually rate this a 3.5, but I round up. I'm so nice. }:c)

CM TK-7764
Rating: 3
21/07/2002 9:19:00 AM


I compared this battle to BoP TC 12 for length. Unlike that battle though, this one as a whole did not flow. I did not really want to fly 7 more missions in this battle. I just wanted it to end so I could have a nice FCHG boost.

MAJ Shae Kitane
Rating: 4
30/07/2002 10:08:00 AM


It's for XvT, you get a nice dozen of FCHG points, there are no "you vs. capital ships" missions (but minefields, yay!) and the battle has a real plot! MindB Productions does more than ASF documentaries! (Okay, it's like a so TC common squadron advertisment battle - which isabsolutely okay! Express the love for your Squad/Wing/BG - but after all that's how people like Ridley Scott earned their first merits... ;) )


XvT-IW Battle #31 - The Antarillo Civil War
Average rating: 3.8 (4 total reviews)
CPT Delak Krennel
Rating: 5
2/07/2002 5:38:00 AM


Excellent Battle. It was well worth the DL.

CM TK-7764
Rating: 4
19/07/2002 11:33:00 AM


Not a single mission lasted for a short period of time (30 seconds I think not). Also liked the interesting use of containers.


XvT-DB Battle #3 - House Ludo Kressh: Battle for Frondra
Average rating: 3 (7 total reviews)
MAJ Frodo
Rating: 4
17/07/2002 11:15:00 AM


Best I've ever flown in XvT DB.


XvT-FREE Mission #29 - Defector
Average rating: 3 (3 total reviews)
LT Jagged Fel
Rating: 2
13/07/2002 4:28:00 PM


A little too easy. Not a bad idea, but you could add a little more surprise and more enemies!


XvT-FREE Mission #46 - Capture the DREAD Sun
Average rating: 4 (3 total reviews)
COL Woobee
Rating: 5
11/07/2002 12:14:00 AM


This mission was a pleasant surprise! The mission was perfect for the TIE Advanced, and the horde of starfighters buzzing around was a decent challenge. All good fun.


XvT-FREE Mission #47 - The CattleGroups: The Bull Sith
Average rating: 4 (2 total reviews)
COL Woobee
Rating: 4
30/07/2002 3:10:00 AM


A funny mission, with good gameplay. Another fine effort Ender!


XvT-FREE Mission #65 - Wing XIII: Phoenix Squadron
Average rating: 4.7 (3 total reviews)
CM TK-7764
Rating: 5
30/07/2002 9:41:00 AM


It is a thinker. You can't win if you don't get a plan for this so don't freak if you lose the first few times.


XvT-FREE Mission #98 - Kill Admiral Ackbar
Average rating: 2 (3 total reviews)
CM TK-7764
Rating: 3
19/07/2002 1:13:00 PM


Strictly blah. Not a great mission but not horrible either.


XvT-FREE Mission #106 - Deadly Food
Average rating: 4 (1 total reviews)
MAJ Frodo
Rating: 4
27/07/2002 10:33:00 AM


This mission was well made and had a good Idea, the only flaw is that it only lasts 1:58min wich is really short for a Free mission, next time more goals should be added:)


BoP-TC Battle #9 - Tiss & Mike: ISD Intrepid
Average rating: 4.7 (3 total reviews)
MAJ Frodo
Rating: 4
14/07/2002 10:45:00 AM


I really like love storys, but this lacked just a tiny bit of extra plotline to be a 5.


BoP-TC Battle #12 - History of Marcin Szydlowski
Average rating: 4.8 (12 total reviews)
MAJ Nurel Turr
Rating: 5
3/07/2002 4:23:00 AM


Very Fun! I had probs with the last 2 missions that were sorted out but once that happened...viola! A battle that is definately on my list of Fav's!!!

CM TK-7764
Rating: 5
15/07/2002 4:35:00 PM


Great battle. A few minor things should be changed but they can be ignored. I wish I could give this battle a rating of 4.7 but I can't go near giving it a 4 so it is a 5.


BoP-FREE Mission #27 - Ambushed
Average rating: 4.3 (3 total reviews)
CPT Alec Qarni
Rating: 4
14/07/2002 5:02:00 PM


A good mission, absolutely nothing wrong with it, although a little fast and perhaps not terribly original. Good if you feel like a little SPing, but don't have time for a battle.


XWA-TC Battle #2 - First Contact
Average rating: 2.9 (22 total reviews)
LCM Hape Unger
Rating: 3
15/07/2002 4:11:00 AM


Nice Battle! In the last mission I´d prefer less capture and more kills :-)

LT Curtis
Rating: 4
18/07/2002 12:12:00 PM


Nice battle pretty well made too, this was one of my first XWA battles and I can say its one of the best so far, Good for the early stuff :)


XWA-TC Battle #7 - Assault on Chimera
Average rating: 4.4 (30 total reviews)
LT Durakon Staely
Rating: 5
13/07/2002 4:38:00 PM


This battle is one of the best battles I've ever played! Tons of rebels to destroy, I like that :)

LCM Renoshi Bespin
Rating: 5
20/07/2002 7:33:00 PM


Despite my initial disappointment that Chimera was a planet and not the Chimera, this is one of my favorite battles. Keep up the good work!


XWA-TC Battle #8 - Hammer to Anvil
Average rating: 4.6 (64 total reviews)
LCM CyberShadow
Rating: 5
30/07/2002 1:35:00 PM


Excellent battle!


XWA-TC Battle #11 - Heroes of the Immortal
Average rating: 4.2 (16 total reviews)
LCM A. G. Snijglau
Rating: 5
7/07/2002 1:19:00 PM


Great battle, swarms of dogfighting is always a plus!


XWA-TC Battle #13 - Hammer to Anvil Part II
Average rating: 4.3 (30 total reviews)
LCM CyberShadow
Rating: 5
29/07/2002 5:02:00 AM


Great battle, the story line is well developed, and the missions are just plain fun to play.


XWA-TC Battle #14 - The History of the ISD Immortal
Average rating: 3.7 (19 total reviews)
LCM Renoshi Bespin
Rating: 2
28/07/2002 11:25:00 AM


Although an enjoyable battle to fly (at certain points), I was most unhappy with the second mission. The ISD Devestator did not have the aid of another ISD and a Interdictor when chasing the Tanitve IV. The Tantive IV would not need an Interdictor to pull it out of hypersapce because Princess Leia wanted to pick up Obi-wan, so she had to stop over Tatooine, nor would the Devestator need to have an Interdictor keep the Tantive IV from jumping into hyperspace because Tatooine's own gravity shadow would prevent such a jump. I find the lack of continuity disturbing.


XWA-TC Battle #17 - Secrets and Lies: The Exile
Average rating: 4.7 (23 total reviews)
LC Zystem Fryar
Rating: 5
18/07/2002 7:47:00 AM


An absolutely awsome Battle.. Nice variety of Ships, missions and best of all a very well laid out plot.
KUDOS on the most enjoyable Mission I've ever played.

LCM CyberShadow
Rating: 5
30/07/2002 1:32:00 PM


Excellent battle, there were a few typos, but overall it was a very well done battle.


XWA-TC Battle #18 - Immortalized
Average rating: 4 (15 total reviews)
CM Furious George
Rating: 3
1/07/2002 5:04:00 AM


Well, it was an ok battle, but a few things were kind of a drag. Mission 4 was hard, and thats ok, as long as there isn't a 3 or 4 minute wait at the start, alas, there was. And in the final mission your wingman kill everything in no time flat, plus the failed mission briefing on mission #4 was a joke.


XWA-TC Battle #19 - Evaluation of the ISD Vanguard
Average rating: 3.2 (8 total reviews)
CM Furious George
Rating: 4
2/07/2002 2:48:00 PM


Nice combination of dogfighting and cap ship fighting, but story was a little weak. No problems with anything in the battle, a nice workout :)

MAJ Archon
Rating: 3
29/07/2002 6:02:00 PM


Above average mission design is marred by a lack of storyline and horrendous briefings and debriefings. The design is nice, providing a good challenge by outnumbering the player, but making sure the enemies attack in waves. Forcing the player to focus on mission objectives while being harassed by enemy fighters is always a good feature,and was implemented well in this battle. Worth the download if you don't care about story too much.


XWA-TC Battle #23 - The Unknown Regions - Thrawn's Fist
Average rating: 4.1 (18 total reviews)
LT Slade Mathers
Rating: 5
3/07/2002 10:50:00 AM


This is the best battle I've ever played!!! The only problem I found was the last mission. It didn't tie in with the rest of the battle and it was boring. Regardless of that I give it a 5. Great Job Master!!!

LT Edward De'Galeon
Rating: 5
23/07/2002 11:40:00 PM


This is a great battle if you have some time and are pretty good at XWA. Even someone who is lacking in XWA skills, such as me, will have a good time with this. It’s got a great plot, some fun missions, and isn’t too frustrating. I really wish they’d avoid making me kill capital ships in a T/A in XWA though, as it gets too hard. Also, I don’t like inspection type recon missions. They all feel the same and I hate them all, just leave them out thank you. Other than that, I really recommend this battle. Go fly it if you have XWA. I give it a 4.60 (rounded up to a 5 for purposes of the EH review scale.)

CM Serge Broskopf
Rating: 3
25/07/2002 10:43:00 AM


Well, it was good. Not excellent, as I must agree with most of the other reviews. The last missions could have been deleted altogether as it has no purpose flying it. The mission before that bothered me a bit as well, as I can't imagine 2 ISDs and 4 VSD assaulting an almost harmless base, only launching 4 T/As and 12 T/Ds and then just sit there and watch. Taking down all cap ships and the base has the player flying back to the ISD getting reloads all over again. It tended to get boring. After finally taking down the base, you think it's all over, only to see there's one more mission, which you can complete by launching and just sitting there. The battle was well constructed, no bugs or construction errors, good story, but it is a shame the waiting and repetitive flying during the last missions made it go downhill. Therefore, I give it a 3.


XWA-TC Battle #25 - Ticket to Chimaera
Average rating: 4.3 (6 total reviews)
LCM A. G. Snijglau
Rating: 4
7/07/2002 8:00:00 PM


This is a great battle for training purposes! Covers all the basics in ultra-difficult terms. Too bad the capture mission was a little buggy....(why were those ATR's ramming the INT?)

CM Serge Broskopf
Rating: 4
29/07/2002 9:13:00 AM


A nice, enjoyable and well constructed battle. Maybe the two first missions were a little short and the capture mission could use a minor touch here and there concerning the errors mentioned in earlier reviews. Because of that, I gave it a 4. But everything else: story, e-mail, fun factor... leave it as it is. Oh... and why no TIE Bomber training mission? :-)


XWA-TC Battle #27 - Battle of Corellia
Average rating: 2.9 (8 total reviews)
CM Furious George
Rating: 4
6/07/2002 5:40:00 AM


I thought it was a great battle, but too many wingmen ruined it for me.


XWA-TC Battle #28 - ViB: The Lost Missions
Average rating: 2 (6 total reviews)
CM Serge Broskopf
Rating: 1
31/07/2002 1:24:00 PM


Er... I'm still trying to figure out what I should call this. First of all, this appears to be a gathering of several loose missions, which do not follow each other up in any way (the note added to mission #3 stating it was originally an Xvt Free mission stressing this). Reading the storyline doc-files doesn't help. I also wondered what the 4th storyline DOC had to do with the 4th mission :/ (2vs2 mp simulated as a mission battle???) Mission #1 had you placed against incredible odds, mission #2 and #4 had you basically do nothing and mission #3 was somewhere in between these. This battle was annoying and terrible to fly. I rated it 1, because all missions were flyable and had no bugs, apart from capital ships flying through each other in mission #1.


XWA-TC Battle #29 - Battle of Sharnall
Average rating: 3.7 (9 total reviews)
LCM BlackHellKnight
Rating: 5
7/07/2002 10:05:00 PM


I was originally going to rate this battle much lower due to kill kill kill on most levels a lot of fighters and one mission took me an hour or a little after i know the clock reset itself anyway. And after i completed one battle i ran into more attacks when i arrived back at the command ship and i became increasingly worried i would fail in case a cap ship was destroyed undoing all my work. but it didnt and i have withdrawal symptoms so i want more battles like this good work!

MAJ Archon
Rating: 1
15/07/2002 9:08:00 PM


It didnt get a 0 because there were no serious bugs that weren't caught by beta testing.
Heres the basic idea, and this is a spoiler because it is all the 6 missions in this battle amount to: Put the player in a T/D (superfighter) and launch horde after horde of inferior fighters (Z-95s, Supas) and see how bored the pilot gets as he slaughters wave after wave after wave of them. There's nothing beyond the simplest of stories, and there is no regard to objectives or completing tasks. Just KILL KILL KILL. Sorry, thats not what makes a good battle in my book. Tell a story and make me fight to get to the next part, not obliterate helpless targets in a turkey shoot for an hour per mission.


XWA-TC Battle #30 - Imperial Storm II: Dark Horizon
Average rating: 2.9 (9 total reviews)
LCM CyberShadow
Rating: 3
11/07/2002 7:23:00 PM


Pretty nice battle, and I know it was based on IS II, but still, there were just too many times when it was me and a squad of fighters vs. a captial ship.


XWA-IW Battle #27 - Rion's Shadow Campaign: Tactical Withdrawal
Average rating: 4.2 (10 total reviews)
LCM Alexi Stukov
Rating: 4
20/07/2002 8:24:00 AM


Well, the campaign is finally over, and it's done in the way it should be. The negotiations with the Rebels was a different approach, although it was annoying sice the Interdictor couldn't be destroyed and I spent about 6 minutes trying to kill it.


XWA-IW Battle #32 - The Valiant and the Immortal
Average rating: 4.5 (13 total reviews)
MAJ RogueWing
Rating: 5
25/07/2002 2:44:00 PM


Nice battle. I give a 5 because so far, this is the only battle on the mission compedium that has a variable ending that depends solely on decisions you make in previous battles.

CPT Abel Malik
Rating: 5
26/07/2002 1:40:00 PM


I flew this in the early stages of the battles development and it rocked! Way to go RW!

VA Darksaber
Rating: 5
28/07/2002 8:04:00 AM


it is a Great battle ;)

Variable Ending rocks. Immortal in IW missions rocks :P

MAJ Mark Schueler
Rating: 5
28/07/2002 1:53:00 PM


This is quality, and it the first ever battle to have a split storyline. Keep `em coming, RW!


XWA-DB Battle #1 - The Forgotten Planet
Average rating: 4.3 (10 total reviews)
CM Furious George
Rating: 4
3/07/2002 12:28:00 AM


Aside from the Y-Wings that didnt shoot back, and the patheticaly easy YT-2400, it was a good battle. All that DB mumbo-jumbo in the debreifings is what got it a 4, just tell me i gotta shoot stuff and it woulda got a 5.


XWA-CAB Battle #1 - Secrets and Lies: Eagles of Freedom
Average rating: 4.7 (13 total reviews)
LT Pedric Cuf
Rating: 5
19/07/2002 6:34:00 AM


Best battle I've ever flown! Can't wait for part 3.


XWA-FCHG Battle #2 - The Forgotten Legacy
Average rating: 4.9 (18 total reviews)
LCM BlackHellKnight
Rating: 5
11/07/2002 8:33:00 PM


Wonderful battle, I'm a big fan of the Thrawn trillogy this battle had all elements of it. plus its made by Striker which is a bonus :-D


XWA-FREE Mission #57 - Wing XV: Hornet Squadron
Average rating: 2 (1 total reviews)
LCM CyberShadow
Rating: 2
30/07/2002 1:36:00 PM


It is a decent mission, except there isn't much of a plot, just dogfighting.